DJ
Quote
Professional Guide

Best Stud Finder for Old Walls: 2025 Expert Review

DJ

DR Joinery

Expert Joiner & Bespoke Fittings Specialist

Published 16 December 2025

If you live in a modern build with crisp plasterboard walls, finding a stud is easy. But for those of us working in older properties with traditional lath and plaster, lime render, or uneven brickwork, it is a different story entirely. Standard electronic stud finders often get confused by the density changes between the timber laths and the plaster keys.

When fitting heavy alcove shelving, hitting the timber stud is critical. A missed fixing typically results in blown plaster, huge dust clouds, and a shelf that won't hold the weight of a hardback book collection.

In this review, I've selected three tools that tackle the unique challenges of old walls: a budget magnetic option (which is often the most reliable method for lath and plaster), a quality electronic scanner for renovated walls, and a multi-purpose detector for safety checks.

Live in York?

struggling with uneven walls?

Get a free quote for bespoke alcove shelving.

Contact Us

Specs vs. The Real World

The Spec: "Deep Scan Mode"

The Theory

"Electronic scanners claim to see through 38mm of material to find the stud centre."

The Reality

In lath and plaster walls, the air gaps and changing density often confuse electronic sensors. They may beep at every lath, not just the upright stud.

The Spec: "Auto-Calibration"

The Theory

"The device calibrates itself against the wall surface for perfect accuracy."

The Reality

On uneven, bowing Victorian walls, you often need to calibrate on a known solid spot first. Relying solely on auto-features can lead to missed fixings.

My Top 3 Recommendations

Three options to cover different needs and budgets

Magnetic Stud Finder [New Packaging], No Battery Screw/Nail in Stud Detector

Budget Pick
Magnetic Stud Finder [New Packaging], No Battery Screw/Nail in Stud Detector

doty

Whilst it might look simple, a strong magnet is often the most effective tool for Victorian lath and plaster walls. Instead of sensing density (which is inconsistent in old walls), this finds the steel clout nails holding the laths to the upright studs. It relies on physics, not sensors, making it incredibly reliable for finding the stud line.

Price£6.99 (at the time of writing)
TypeMagnetic
PowerNo batteries required
The Good
  • Does not get confused by lath and plaster density changes
  • No batteries required - always ready in the toolbox
  • Compact size fits easily in a pocket
The Bad
  • Does not detect live wires (requires care)
  • Cannot find the centre or edge of the stud, only the fixing nail

Installer Tip:

Use a circular motion. Once the magnet 'grabs' a nail, mark it with a pencil. Find another nail vertically above or below it. The line connecting these two points is the centre of your stud.

Priced at £6.99 at the time of writing

Check Price on Amazon

Stud Finder Wall Scanner 6 in 1 – Upgraded Stud Detector with LCD Display

Quality Pick
Stud Finder Wall Scanner 6 in 1 – Upgraded Stud Detector with LCD Display

aquota

If your alcoves have been over-boarded with modern plasterboard or dot-and-dab, this electronic scanner is superior. The 6-in-1 functionality allows you to distinguish between timber studs, metal partitioning, and piping. The backlit LCD is excellent for working in poorly lit corners of a room.

Price£22.09 (at the time of writing)
Modes6-in-1 (Stud, Metal, Live Wire, Joist, Pipe)
DisplayLCD with 3-Colour LED
The Good
  • Live AC wire detection adds a layer of safety
  • Clear LCD display shows the centre of the stud
  • Auto calibation simplifies use on standard walls
The Bad
  • Cannot scan through metal mesh or tiles
  • Struggles on very thick original lime plaster

Installer Tip:

When using the deep scan mode, move the device slowly. If you move too fast over an uneven wall, the sensor will throw a false reading. Mark the left edge and the right edge of the signal to find the true centre for your bracket screws.

Priced at £22.09 at the time of writing

Check Price on Amazon

Mecurate Stud Finder Wall Scanner Sensor - 5 in 1 Electronic Stud with LCD Display

Problem Solver
Mecurate Stud Finder Wall Scanner Sensor - 5 in 1 Electronic Stud with LCD Display

Mecurate

Old houses are full of surprises, including random pipes and erratic wiring routes. This multi-mode scanner is excellent for 'medical imaging' your wall before you drill. The dedicated Metal and AC modes are particularly sensitive, helping you map out safe zones for your shelving brackets.

Price£19.54 (at the time of writing)
Detection DepthUp to 38mm (Deep Mode), 60mm (Metal)
SafetyAudio alarm for AC wires
The Good
  • Deep scan mode helps penetrate thicker plaster layers
  • Audio alerts ensure you don't miss warning signs
  • Good balance of features for the price
The Bad
  • Requires 9V battery (included but will need replacing)
  • Performance drops on textured wallpaper

Installer Tip:

Always verify your findings. If the scanner indicates a stud, tap the wall with your knuckle. A dull thud confirms timber; a hollow sound suggests the scanner might be picking up a loose lath or debris inside the cavity.

Priced at £19.54 at the time of writing

Check Price on Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

Why won't my standard stud finder work on my old house walls?
Standard stud finders work by detecting density changes behind uniform plasterboard. In older properties (especially pre-1950s), walls are often 'lath and plaster'. This consists of hundreds of horizontal wooden strips (laths) with gaps between them. The electronic sensor gets confused by the constant change from wood to plaster key, often causing it to beep continuously or not at all.
What is the best way to find a stud in lath and plaster walls?
The most reliable method is often a strong magnet (like the Doty reviewed above). Instead of looking for the wooden stud itself, you look for the iron nails used to fix the horizontal laths to the vertical studs. When you find a vertical line of magnetic attractions, you have found your stud line.
Can I simply use wall plugs if I can't find a stud?
For heavy loads like books on alcove shelving, relying solely on wall plugs in old plaster is risky. The plaster can crumble, pulling the plug out. Ideally, you want at least one fixing into timber. If you must use plugs, consider chemical anchors or specialist toggle fixings that grip behind the lath, rather than expanding into the crumbling plaster.
How deep are studs usually buried in old walls?
It varies significantly. In modern plasterboard, it is usually 12.5mm. In Victorian homes, you might have 5-10mm of plaster, then 20-30mm of lath and lime, meaning the solid stud could be 30-40mm deep. This is why standard screws are often too short; we generally recommend using screws at least 60mm-70mm long for fixing brackets in these properties.
Do I need professional help for fitting alcove shelves?
If your walls are very uneven, bowed, or crumbling, achieving a level shelf that can take weight requires significant skill in scribing and fixing. If you are unsure about the structural integrity of your walls, it is worth consulting a joiner. DR Joinery specialises in bespoke fittings for difficult spaces in York.

Need Professional Alcove Shelving & Storage?

Our team at DR Joinery specialises in Alcove Shelving & Storage across York.

Get a free quote for professional installation.

View Our Alcove Shelving & Storage Service