Best Sash Window Fasteners for Security and Style: 2025 Expert Review
DR Joinery
Expert Joiner & Bespoke Fittings Specialist
A sash window fastener does more than just lock your window; it's the primary mechanism for pulling the meeting rails together to create a seal against drafts and damp. In York's older properties, where nothing is ever truly square, choosing the right fastener is critical for both security and comfort.
Many homeowners make the mistake of buying cheap, lightweight fasteners that snap under pressure or struggle to engage when sashes have been painted over too many times. Restoration isn't just about replacing rot; it's about ensuring the window functions smoothly.
In this review, I'll compare three fasteners I've encountered on site: a budget-friendly fitch pattern, a high-quality sprung Brighton fastener, and a reliable standard option for general repairs.
Live in York?
Windows rattling or rotting?
Get a free quote from our local team.
Specs vs. The Real World
The Spec: "Security Claims"
"A standard fastener is sufficient to secure the window against intruders."
Fasteners primarily seal the window. For genuine security, especially on ground floors in city centres, you must fit restrictors or sash stops. A simple fitch fastener can often be forced open from the outside with a knife.
The Spec: "Universal Fit"
"Any fastener will fit any sash window."
If your meeting rails (the middle bit of the window) aren't flush due to warping or layers of old paint, a standard fitch won't engage. You may need a Brighton fastener or, more likely, professional re-balancing and planing of the joinery.
My Top 3 Recommendations
Three options to cover different needs and budgets
Merriway® BH01749 EB Sash Window Fitch Fastener Lock - Brass Plated
Merriway
This is a classic 'Fitch' pattern fastener. Priced at under £4, it's a functional choice for landlords or budget renovations where you need to replace missing hardware quickly. It's brass plated rather than solid brass, so it's best for low-traffic windows.
The Good
- Extremely affordable
- Classic semi-circle design fits most standard sashes
- Includes screws (though I recommend using longer pilot-drilled screws)
The Bad
- Plating will wear eventually, unlike solid brass
- Mechanism can feel a bit loose compared to premium options
Installer Tip:
Because this is plated metal, be very careful not to scratch it with your screwdriver during fitting, as moisture will get under the plating and cause rust. Always pre-drill your holes, especially in old, seasoned Victorian timber.
Priced at £3.41 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonSolid Brighton Lever Lock Sash Window Fastener Twist Catch Latch + Screws (Satin Nickel)
Chivrose Ltd
The 'Brighton' fastener is a step up from the standard fitch. This Chivrose model is sprung-loaded, meaning the arm won't flop about and rattle when the window is unlocked. The satin nickel finish offers a contemporary look for modernised period properties.
The Good
- Spring-loaded arm prevents rattling when unlocked
- Screw pulls the sashes together tightly for a better draft seal
- Modern satin finish suits contemporary interiors
The Bad
- Requires the meeting rails to be perfectly level to work best
- Higher price point per window
Installer Tip:
Brighton fasteners are excellent, but they are unforgiving. Ensure your meeting rails are flush. If the top sash sits slightly back from the bottom one (common in old houses), you might need to chisel a small rebate for the keep or use a packer to align them.
Priced at £9.99 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonMerriway BH01890 Sash Window Fastener EB, Brass
Merriway
This fastener sits in the middle ground. It features a robust cam action designed to actively pull the two sashes together. I categorise this as 'problem-solving' because its primary job is rectifying wider gaps between checking rails that cause drafts.
The Good
- Good clamping force to reduce drafts
- Mid-range price offers better longevity than budget options
- Traditional appearance matches existing Victorian hardware
The Bad
- Like other brass finishes, it will tarnish over time if not polished
- Requires accurate alignment during installation
Installer Tip:
If your sashes have been painted shut or have thick paint buildup, scrape the meeting rails back to bare wood before fitting this. The cam action needs a clean surface to pull the sashes tight effectively.
Priced at £5.40 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonFrequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a Fitch and a Brighton fastener?
Can I replace sash fasteners myself?
Do sash fasteners improve security?
Why do my sash windows still rattle after fitting new fasteners?
Need Professional Sash Window Restoration?
Our team at DR Joinery specialises in Sash Window Restoration across York.
Get a free quote for professional installation.
View Our Sash Window Restoration Service