Best Post Hole Diggers for Fencing: 2025 Expert Review
DR Joinery
Expert Joiner & Fencing Specialist
If there is one job that tests a person's patience, it is digging fence post holes by hand. In York, we are often battling heavy clay, hidden bricks from old demolished outbuildings, or compacted stone. Attempting this with a standard garden spade is a recipe for wide, messy holes that waste concrete and lack stability.
A proper post hole digger is essential for creating the narrow, deep holes required for a professional finish. It minimises the amount of soil you need to remove and the amount of Postcrete required to secure the timber.
In this review, I've selected three manual digging tools that cover different needs: a budget-friendly auger for softer ground, a heavy-duty 'clamshell' digger for the professional, and a reliable mid-range option for deep excavation.
Live in York?
Dreading the digging?
Our team handles the hard graft so you don't have to.
Specs vs. The Real World
The Spec: " 'Easy to Use' Claims"
"Marketing materials often suggest the tool glides into the earth with minimal effort."
In heavy UK clay or stony ground, manual digging is always hard physical labour. Augers can get stuck on roots, and clamshell diggers require significant upper body strength to snap shut.
The Spec: "Root Cutting Ability"
"Serrated blades will slice through tree roots easily."
While serrated edges help with small feeder roots, anything thicker than a finger will usually stop a manual digger dead. You will likely need a heavy steel digging bar or mattock alongside these tools.
My Top 3 Recommendations
Three options to cover different needs and budgets
Fence Post Auger,Post Hole Digger Hand Drill, 10X60cm
Eidoct
This is a simple, no-nonsense auger screw tool. Ideally suited for garden projects where the ground isn't too compacted. It creates a neat 10cm hole which is perfect for smaller posts or planting, but it may struggle with the heavy clay often found in York.
The Good
- Very affordable option for small jobs
- Creates a clean, round hole with minimal spoil
- Lightweight and easy to transport
The Bad
- Short handle (60cm) limits the depth of the hole significantly
- Struggles in stony ground or heavy clay
- Require significant torque strength to turn in compacted soil
Installer Tip:
Use this tool to start your pilot hole. Once you hit the 60cm limit or harder ground, you may need to switch to a longer tool. Keep a file handy to keep the leading edge sharp.
Priced at £13.59 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonRoughneck Sharp-Edge Post Hole Digger - Solid Fibreglass Handle
Roughneck
Roughneck is a brand I trust on site. This is a heavy-duty 'clamshell' style digger with serrated blades that actually bite into the ground. The weight of the tool works in your favour, helping to drive it into the soil with momentum rather than just brute force.
The Good
- Serrated hardened steel blades cut through tough soil effectively
- Solid fibreglass handles won't rot or snap under pressure
- Built-in depth gauge on the handle is a brilliant time-saver
The Bad
- Higher price point, but worth it for longevity
- Heavier to lift repeatedly (though the weight helps digging)
Installer Tip:
The technique here is 'slam, wiggle, snap, lift'. Slam it down, wiggle slightly to settle the blades, snap the handles together to grab the soil, and lift with your legs, not your back. The depth gauge is excellent for ensuring all your fence posts sit at the exact same level.
Priced at £54.99 at the time of writing
Check Price on Amazon1450mm Heavy Duty Fence Post Hole Soil Digger Auger
Easy Shopping
Sometimes you need to go deep to get past frost lines or unstable topsoil. This tool offers a balance between cost and performance, with a long handle design that allows for deep, narrow excavation without widening the hole unnecessarily.
The Good
- Extra length allows for digging deep post holes (crucial for tall fences)
- Fibreglass handles offer durability and weather resistance
- Narrow head design saves on concrete volume
The Bad
- Not as heavy-duty as the Roughneck
- Grips can slip slightly when wet compared to premium brands
Installer Tip:
Use this for the final 200mm of your hole. A standard spade can do the top section, but this tool is perfect for cleaning out the bottom of the hole ('bottoming out') to ensure your timber post sits on a flat, solid base rather than a tapered point.
Priced at £28.90 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonFrequently Asked Questions
How deep should I dig for a fence post?
Is an auger better than a clamshell digger?
What if the ground is too hard to dig manually?
Can DR Joinery install the fence if I can't manage the digging?
Need Professional Timber Decking & Fencing?
Our team at DR Joinery specialises in Timber Decking & Fencing across York.
Get a free quote for professional installation.
View Our Timber Decking & Fencing Service