Best Door Threshold Sills for UK Homes: 2025 Expert Review
DR Joinery
Expert Joiner & Proprietor
The door threshold is often the unsung hero of your home's thermal efficiency. In my years working across York, particularly in Victorian terraces and listed buildings, I've seen how a failing sill can lead to rot, damp, and significant heat loss. It's usually the first point of failure in an external door set.
Many homeowners confuse the structural sill (often timber or stone) with the threshold bar or weather bar that sits atop it. Whether you are looking to replace a perished rubber seal or protect a worn wooden sill with a metal cover, selecting the right product is crucial for longevity.
In this review, I've selected three specific products that solve different problems: a budget-friendly seal replacement for maintenance, a premium brass cover for heritage aesthetics, and a robust stainless steel option for damaged high-traffic areas.
Live in York?
Drafty doors or rotting sills?
Get a free quote for a professional repair or replacement.
Specs vs. The Real World
The Spec: "Universal Fit"
"Manufacturers often claim threshold bars will fit any standard door opening."
In York's older properties, 'standard' doesn't exist. Frames shift, sills bow, and rebate sizes vary. You will almost always need to cut these bars to size with a decent hacksaw or grinder.
The Spec: "Stops All Draughts"
"Fitting a new threshold strip will instantly cure a cold hallway."
The threshold is only half the battle. If the door itself is warped or the side seals are gone, you'll still feel a chill. A threshold works best as part of a complete draught-proofing system.
My Top 3 Recommendations
Three options to cover different needs and budgets
Exitex DSS Replacement Door Threshold Seal, Black, 914mm
Exitex
This isn't a full metal threshold, but rather the rubber insert that typically perishes after a few years. It's a cost-effective way to restore the seal on existing Exitex or Macclex type thresholds without ripping out the entire frame screws.
The Good
- Extremely cost-effective repair solution
- Saves replacing the entire metal aluminium threshold bar
- Compatible with the most common UK threshold profiles
The Bad
- Only solves the problem if the rubber component is the issue
- Requires manual dexterity to slide into the existing groove
Installer Tip:
Do not stretch the rubber when sliding it into the groove. Push it in gently. If you stretch it, it will eventually shrink back, leaving gaps at the ends where draughts can enter.
Priced at £7.99 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonThreshold Brass Door Sill Cover (920 Brass)
Avonstar Classics Range
For period properties in York, a bright aluminium strip often looks out of place against aged stone or timber. This solid brass cover offers a premium finish that serves to protect the underlying sill from foot traffic while looking the part.
The Good
- Solid 1.2mm brass is incredibly durable
- Aesthetically superior for Victorian or Edwardian homes
- Protects the structural timber sill from boot scuffs and water ingress
The Bad
- Brass requires polishing to stop tarnishing (unless lacquered)
- Significantly heavier and harder to cut than aluminium
Installer Tip:
Brass sits beautifully on oak thresholds. If fixing to stone, use a high-quality grip adhesive (like CT1) rather than drilling, to avoid cracking the stone step. Ensure the brass is completely bonded to stop water tracking underneath.
Priced at £34.95 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonThreshold Door Sill Cover (820 Wide) - Stainless Steel
Avonstar Classics Range
This is my go-to solution when a wooden sill is looking tired or has superficial damage but isn't rotten enough to warrant a full replacement. The 304-grade stainless steel covers a multitude of sins and provides a robust, cleanable surface for high-traffic back doors.
The Good
- 304 Grade steel will not rust, suitable for external use
- Brushed finish hides scratches better than polished options
- Excellent for covering splintered or worn wooden sills
The Bad
- Industrial look might not suit a formal front door
- Fixed size means you must measure your depth accurately
Installer Tip:
Before fitting this over a wooden sill, ensure the timber is dry and treat it with a preservative. Covering damp wood with steel will just accelerate rot. Bed the steel on a bead of clear external silicone to seal the gap.
Priced at £19.95 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonFrequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a door sill and a threshold?
How do I cut a metal threshold sill to size?
My wooden sill is rotten. Will a cover fix it?
Does a threshold sill stop water ingress?
Need Professional Internal & External Door Fitting?
Our team at DR Joinery specialises in Internal & External Door Fitting across York.
Get a free quote for professional installation.
View Our Internal & External Door Fitting Service